I wanted something that would appeal to everyone so I decided to do a 1 year magazine subscription. It's not a huge list but you get to pick which magazine you'd like to get free for a year. I'll be buying this with my Coke Points and the nifty thing is I often get other magazines sent to me free by the same publishing company so your 1 magazine subscription could turn in to several.
The choices are (all are 1 year unless otherwise noted):
Family Circle (15 issues)
Better Homes and Gardens
Ready Made (6 issues, the magazine comes out every 2 months)
Whoever wins gets to choose from the list.